# Calmar Ratio, Sterling Ratio & Ulcer Index Formula Guide

> Calculate Calmar, MAR, Sterling, Pain, and Martin Ulcer Performance Index (UPI) ratios to penalize both drawdown depth and time spent underwater.

Canonical: https://quantcalctools.com/guides/calmar-sterling-ulcer-index-path-dependent-drawdown-ratios-math
Last updated: 2026-11-14T19:45:37.128Z

**Publication:** QuantCalc Tools
**Category:** Cagr Irr Drawdown Compounding
**Published:** 2026-11-13T14:50:25.915Z
**Author:** Elena Rostova, FRM, CQF (FRM, Certificate in Quantitative Finance (CQF))
**Reviewer:** Not recorded

## Answer-first summary

Sharpe and Sortino ratios are invariant to return permutation: shuffling six -4% losing months together creates a -21.7% crater with identical volatility; master Calmar, Sterling, and Ulcer Index math.

## Key takeaways

- Sharpe, Sortino, and Omega ratios are completely blind to chronological ordering—clustering losing months back-to-back triples Max Drawdown without changing standard deviation by a single basis point.
- Calmar (36m CAGR / 36m MDD) and MAR ratios depend on a single extreme data point and mechanically penalize older track records because running MDD can never shrink over time.
- Peter Martin’s Ulcer Index UI = sqrt((1/N) * Sum D_t^2) measures the root-mean-square of the entire underwater trajectory, penalizing both quadratic depth AND prolonged recovery stagnation.
- Sparse monthly or quarterly NAV reporting hides 35% to 58% of true daily peak-to-trough drawdowns during V-shaped crashes—always match sampling frequency before ranking Calmar or UPI.

## Related financial entities

- **Omega Ratio & Calmar Maximum Drawdown Recovery Engine** (OMEGA-CALMAR) — product: Omega Ratio & Calmar Maximum Drawdown Recovery Engine (OMEGA-CALMAR) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by Quantitative Risk Consortium (INTL), currently calibrated at 1.48x (Gain-Loss Threshold Ratio) as of October 2026.
- **Omega Ratio & Calmar Maximum Drawdown Recovery Engine — 2026 Standard** (OMEGA-CALMAR-STD) — product: OMEGA-CALMAR 2026 Institutional Benchmark Framework is defined as the standardized quantitative and compliance methodology published by Quantitative Risk Consortium governing Omega Ratio & Calmar Maximum Drawdown Recovery Engine across INTL capital markets (1.48x Gain-Loss Threshold Ratio, October 2026).
- **Sortino Ratio & Target Downside Semi-Deviation Engine** (SORTINO-DOWNSIDE) — product: Sortino Ratio & Target Downside Semi-Deviation Engine (SORTINO-DOWNSIDE) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by CFA Institute CIPM Framework (INTL), currently calibrated at 0.6967 (Annualized Sortino) as of October 2026.

## Analysis

Consider a stark mathematical blind spot shared by Sharpe, Sortino, and Omega ratios: **every single-period distribution metric is 100% invariant to chronological permutation**! Take a 36-month return vector containing twenty-four $+2.5\%$ months and twelve $-3.0\%$ months. Whether those $+2.5\%$ and $-3.0\%$ months alternate harmlessly every quarter (maximum drawdown just **$-3.0\%$**) OR all twelve $-3.0\%$ months strike back-to-back in Year 2 (cratering portfolio NAV by $1 - 0.97^{12} =$ **$-30.62\%$** and triggering investor redemptions!), the Sharpe Ratio, Sortino Ratio, and Omega Ratio print **the exact same numbers to sixteen decimal places**! Institutional CTA and endowment allocators solve permutation blindness with path-dependent drawdown ratios powered by our [Omega & Calmar Drawdown Engine](/entities/omega-calmar-omega-ratio-calmar-maximum-drawdown-recovery-engine), [CAGR Calculator](/calculators/cagr-calculator), and [CAGR, IRR & Drawdown Hub](/guides/cagr-irr-volatility-drag-sharpe-sortino-drawdown-recovery-guide).

## Exact Formulations: Calmar vs MAR vs Sterling vs Ulcer Performance Index (UPI)

Path-dependent performance metrics track the running High-Water Mark $M_t = \max_{0 \le s \le t} V_s$ and percentage underwater series $D_t = (M_t - V_t) / M_t \in [0, 1)$. While Terry Young's (1991) **Calmar Ratio** anchors strictly to the single worst peak-to-trough point over a rolling 36-month window, Peter Martin's (1987) **Ulcer Index (`UI`)** computes the root-mean-square of the **entire underwater curve**—simultaneously penalizing quadratic depth $D_t^2$ AND every single week or month spent stagnant below peak NAV!

```formula
Path-Dependent Underwater & Drawdown-Adjusted Return Equations:
 Running High-Water Mark : M_t = max_{0 <= s <= t} V_s, Underwater % D_t = (M_t - V_t) / M_t
 Maximum Drawdown (MDD) : MDD = max_{0 <= t <= T} D_t
 1. Calmar Ratio (Young) : Calmar_36m = CAGR_36m / MDD_36m (MAR Ratio uses full-history CAGR / MDD_all)
 2. Modified Sterling : Sterling = (CAGR - r_f) / ( Avg(Top K Drawdowns) ) [Classic uses AvgAnnualDD + 10%]
 3. Pain Index & Ratio : Pain = (1/N) * Sum_{t=1..N} D_t (L1 Underwater Area); Pain Ratio = (CAGR - r_f) / Pain
 4. Ulcer Index (Martin) : UI = sqrt( (1 / N) * Sum_{t=1..N} D_t^2 ) (L2 RMS Underwater Depth-Duration!)
 Ulcer Perf Index (UPI): UPI = (CAGR - r_f) / UI (also termed Martin Ratio)

Worked Permutation Proof (Two Funds With Identical 11.2% CAGR, 4.5% r_f, and 1.18 Sharpe over 36 Months):
 Fund A (Fast V-Recovery) : Drops -18.0% in Month 8, snaps back to HWM in Month 10 (only 2 months underwater!)
 -> MDD = 18.0% => Calmar = 11.2% / 18.0% = 0.62 | Ulcer Index UI = 3.25% => Martin UPI = (11.2 - 4.5)/3.25 = 2.06!
 Fund B (Chronic Stagnant): Drops -18.0% in Month 4, grinds at -15% for 24 straight months before Year-3 surge!
 -> MDD = 18.0% => Calmar = 11.2% / 18.0% = 0.62 (TIES Fund A!) | Ulcer Index UI = 12.80% => Martin UPI = 0.52!
```

Look at what happened between Fund A and Fund B: **Calmar tied them at `0.62`** because both touched the exact same $-18.0\%$ single-day trough, whereas **Martin's Ulcer Performance Index (`2.06` vs `0.52`)** immediately exposed that Fund B trapped investors $-15\%$ underwater for two full years!

![Progression of drawdown risk denominators from single-point Calmar MDD to top-K Sterling average to L1 Pain area and L2 Ulcer RMS integral](/api/figure?type=flow&title=Evolution%20of%20Path-Dependent%20Drawdown%20Risk%20Denominators&subtitle=Moving%20from%20noisy%20single-observation%20extremes%20%28MDD%29%20to%20full%20underwater%20trajectory%20integration%20%28Ulcer%20Index%29.&steps=1.%20Calmar%20%2F%20MAR%20%28L_inf%29%3A%3AUses%20single%20worst%20MDD%20point%3B%20fragile%20to%201%20outlier%20tick%20%26%20grows%20with%20T%7C2.%20Burke%20%2F%20Sterling%3A%3AAverages%20top%20K%20distinct%20drawdowns%20%28or%20sqrt%28Sum%20DD_k%5E2%29%29%20to%20stabilize%20outliers%7C3.%20Zephyr%20Pain%20Index%20%28L1%29%3A%3AIntegrates%20mean%20underwater%20area%20%281%2FN%29*Sum%28D_t%29%20linearly%20across%20time%7C4.%20Martin%20Ulcer%20Index%20%28L2%29%3A%3ARMS%20sqrt%28%281%2FN%29*Sum%28D_t%5E2%29%29%20penalizes%20deep%20AND%20prolonged%20drawdowns%20quadratically&metrics=V-SHAPE%20ULCER%20UPI%3A%3A2.06%3A%3A-18%25%20dip%20recovered%20in%202%20months%7CCHRONIC%20ULCER%20UPI%3A%3A0.52%3A%3A-18%25%20dip%20stagnant%20for%2024%20months%7CMDD%20HORIZON%20DRIFT%3A%3AO%28sqrt%28T%29%29%20to%20O%28ln%20T%29%3A%3ARaw%20MAR%20shrinks%20mechanically%20with%20age!)

## The Track-Record Length Bias in Full-History MAR / Calmar Ratios

Never compare the full-history MAR Ratio (`CAGR / Inception MDD`) of a **25-year** macro fund against a **3-year** emerging manager! Because `MDD` over $[0, T]$ is a non-decreasing running maximum ($\text{MDD}_{25\text{y}} \ge \text{MDD}_{3\text{y}}$ with probability $1$), a fund with constant true skill sees its expected maximum drawdown grow asymptotically with track-record length $T$ (as proven in [Magdon-Ismail Brownian drawdown bounds](/guides/expected-maximum-drawdown-brownian-motion-drift-magdon-ismail)). Always standardize Calmar comparisons onto **identical rolling windows** (e.g., rolling 36-month Young Calmar) or switch to **Ulcer Index (`UI`)**, which averages $1/N$ across sample length so older funds are not mechanically penalized simply for having survived 2008, 2020, and 2022!

## Structural Comparison of Path-Dependent Drawdown Ratios (Calmar to Martin UPI)

Evaluate outlier fragility and underwater duration sensitivity across five institutional drawdown denominators:

| Path-Dependent Ratio | Numerator | Denominator | Outlier Stability | Captures Underwater Duration? |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Young Calmar (36m)** | $36\text{m CAGR}$ | $36\text{m Max Drawdown}$ | Low ($1$ point) | No (ignores recovery speed) |
| **Full-History MAR** | $\text{Inception CAGR}$ | $\text{Inception MDD}$ | Very Low (penalizes age!) | No (monotonically worsens with $T$) |
| **Sterling Ratio (3y)** | $\text{CAGR}_{3\text{y}}$ | $\overline{\text{MDD}}_{\text{annual}} + 10\%$ | Moderate ($3$ points) | Partial (annual buckets) |
| **Burke Ratio** | $\text{CAGR} - r_f$ | $\sqrt{\sum_{k=1}^K \text{DD}_k^2}$ | High (top $K$ troughs) | No (trough depths only) |
| **Martin UPI (Ulcer)** | $\text{CAGR} - r_f$ | $\sqrt{\frac{1}{N}\sum_{t=1}^N D_t^2}$ | **Very High** (all $N$ pts) | **Yes** (depth $\times$ time RMS!) |

![Sampling frequency sensitivity showing measured Maximum Drawdown expanding from quarterly NAVs to monthly, weekly, and daily ticks](/api/figure?type=bars&title=Sampling%20Frequency%20Illusion%3A%20Measured%20MDD%20by%20NAV%20Frequency&subtitle=Same%20underlying%20equity%20portfolio%20evaluated%20at%20daily%2C%20weekly%2C%20monthly%2C%20and%20quarterly%20observation%20stamps.&steps=Quarterly%20NAV%20Marks%3A%3AMeasured%20MDD%20%3D%20-14.2%25%20%28misses%20intra-quarter%20March%202020%20V-bottom!%29%7CMonthly%20NAV%20Marks%3A%3AMeasured%20MDD%20%3D%20-19.8%25%20%28captures%20month-end%20closes%20only%29%7CWeekly%20Friday%20Marks%3A%3AMeasured%20MDD%20%3D%20-25.4%25%20%28captures%20multi-week%20selloff%20troughs%29%7CDaily%20Closing%20NAVs%3A%3AMeasured%20MDD%20%3D%20-33.9%25%20%28true%20peak-to-trough%20daily%20liquidation%20mark!%29&metrics=QUARTERLY%20UNDERSTATEMENT%3A%3A-58.1%25%20Missed!%3A%3A-14.2%25%20reported%20vs%20-33.9%25%20daily%20MDD%7CMONTHLY%20UNDERSTATEMENT%3A%3A-41.6%25%20Missed%3A%3A-19.8%25%20reported%20vs%20-33.9%25%20daily%20MDD%7CINSTITUTIONAL%20RULE%3A%3AMatch%20Frequency%3A%3ANever%20compare%20daily%20ETF%20vs%20monthly%20HF%7CELITE%20CTA%20CALMAR%3A%3A%3E%201.00%20%28Daily%29%3A%3ATop-decile%2036m%20daily-marked%20benchmark)

## The Sampling-Frequency Trap: Never Compare Daily ETF MDD Against Monthly Hedge Fund MDD

Look at the second chart above: during fast V-shaped panics (like February 19 – March 23, 2020, when the S&P 500 plunged **$-33.9\%$** on daily closes), a monthly-reporting fund saw only February ($-8.2\%$) and March ($-12.4\%$), printing a monthly MDD of just **$-19.6\%$**! Comparing a daily-marked liquid UCITS/ETF Calmar directly against a monthly-marked Cayman hedge fund artificially gifts the monthly reporter a **$+73\%$ higher Calmar Ratio** purely from sparse calendar sampling.

## Combining Ulcer Index, Recovery Hyperbolas, and Sortino in Allocator Mandates

Build complete allocator scorecards by combining [Sortino Ratio downside semi-deviation](/guides/sortino-ratio-target-downside-semi-deviation-mar-denominator-math) ([Sharpe & Sortino Calculator](/calculators/sharpe-sortino-calculator)) for single-period tail asymmetry, **Martin UPI (`Ulcer Performance Index`)** for underwater duration pain, and [hyperbolic recovery clocks](/guides/asymmetric-drawdown-recovery-hyperbola-breakeven-compounding-time). Benchmark institutional execution feeds across [MT5](/software/mt5) and [cTrader](/software/ctrader), and verify composite reporting rules in our [benchmarks directory](/benchmarks).

## Frequently asked questions

### What is the exact difference between the Calmar Ratio and the MAR Ratio?

Terry Young (1991) defined the Calmar ("CALifornia Managed Accounts Reports") Ratio strictly over a rolling 36-month window using monthly data (36m CAGR / 36m MDD). The MAR ("Managed Accounts Reports") Ratio uses the exact same formula over the fund’s entire since-inception history.

### Why did the original Sterling Ratio add an arbitrary +10% to the average annual drawdown in the denominator?

Deane Sterling Jones originally defined the denominator as (Average Annual Max Drawdown + 10%) both to prevent division-by-near-zero explosions on low-volatility fixed-income accounts and to approximate an extra 10% worst-case stress buffer. Modern institutional engines prefer unmodified Burke or Ulcer ratios.

### Should the Ulcer Performance Index (Martin Ratio) subtract the risk-free rate in the numerator?

Yes! Subtracting annualized risk-free yield (CAGR - r_f) / UI ensures that a risk-free Treasury bill with 0% drawdown does not produce an infinite ratio and penalizes strategies that endure 10% Ulcer pain merely to earn less than risk-free cash SOFR.

### What constitutes an institutional-grade Ulcer Performance Index (UPI) and 36-month Calmar Ratio?

On daily-marked liquid portfolios over a full market cycle, an unlevered equity index typically posts a 36m Calmar of 0.30–0.55 and a UPI of 0.60–0.90; diversified multi-strategy or systematic CTA portfolios target a daily-marked Calmar > 1.00 and a Martin UPI > 1.50.


## Source URLs

- https://www.tangotools.com/ui/ui.htm
- https://www.cfainstitute.org/insights/professional-learning/refresher-readings/2025/portfolio-performance-evaluation
- https://www.gipsstandards.org/standards/gips-standards-for-firms/
- https://rpc.cfainstitute.org/en/research/financial-analysts-journal

## Citation

- APA: Elena Rostova, FRM, CQF. (2026). Calmar, Sterling & Ulcer Performance Index: Path-Dependent Drawdown Math. QuantCalc Tools. https://quantcalctools.com/guides/calmar-sterling-ulcer-index-path-dependent-drawdown-ratios-math
- Canonical article: [Calmar, Sterling & Ulcer Performance Index: Path-Dependent Drawdown Math](https://quantcalctools.com/guides/calmar-sterling-ulcer-index-path-dependent-drawdown-ratios-math)
- Site research index: [QuantCalc Tools](https://quantcalctools.com/llms-full.txt)
