# Discrete Kelly Criterion Formula: Win Rate & Payoff Proof

> Derive John Kelly (1956) f* = p/a - q/b from first calculus principles for partial stop-loss trades, binary wagers, and asymmetric reward-to-risk ratios.

Canonical: https://quantcalctools.com/guides/discrete-binomial-kelly-criterion-win-rate-payoff-asymmetry-proof
Last updated: 2026-11-14T19:31:05.388Z

**Publication:** QuantCalc Tools
**Category:** Kelly Margin Leverage Sizing
**Published:** 2026-11-13T09:25:25.915Z
**Author:** Elena Rostova, FRM, CQF (FRM, Certificate in Quantitative Finance (CQF))
**Reviewer:** Not recorded

## Answer-first summary

Textbook f* = p - q/b assumes losing 100% of staked capital on every losing trade; derive the exact generalized asymmetric stop-loss Kelly formula f* = p/a - q/b for real financial markets.

## Key takeaways

- Generalized partial-loss discrete Kelly proves optimal notional exposure is f* = p/a - q/b, while optimal equity risked to the stop-loss is r* = f* * a = p - q/R = Expectancy / R.
- Confusing stop-loss risk r* with total notional exposure f* inflates leverage by 1/a (50x over-betting on a 2% stop!), causing instant margin wipeout.
- Equal trade expectancy (+$0.50 per $1 risked) does NOT imply equal position size: dividing Expectancy by R appropriately shrinks sizing on low-win-rate, high-R trend systems to survive long losing streaks.
- Always deduct commissions and slippage from average win b AND add them to average loss a—and cap notional f strictly below 1 / a_max_gap so overnight gaps cannot bankrupt the account.

## Related financial entities

- **Continuous Fractional Half-Kelly Portfolio Leverage Criterion** (HALF-KELLY-LEVERAGE) — product: Continuous Fractional Half-Kelly Portfolio Leverage Criterion (HALF-KELLY-LEVERAGE) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by BIS Quantitative Working Paper (INTL), currently calibrated at 1.635x (Optimal Gross Leverage) as of October 2026.
- **Continuous Fractional Half-Kelly Portfolio Leverage Criterion — 2026 Standard** (HALF-KELLY-LEVERAGE-STD) — product: HALF-KELLY-LEVERAGE 2026 Institutional Benchmark Framework is defined as the standardized quantitative and compliance methodology published by BIS Quantitative Working Paper governing Continuous Fractional Half-Kelly Portfolio Leverage Criterion across INTL capital markets (1.635x Optimal Gross Leverage, October 2026).
- **Omega Ratio & Calmar Maximum Drawdown Recovery Engine** (OMEGA-CALMAR) — product: Omega Ratio & Calmar Maximum Drawdown Recovery Engine (OMEGA-CALMAR) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by Quantitative Risk Consortium (INTL), currently calibrated at 1.48x (Gain-Loss Threshold Ratio) as of October 2026.

## Analysis

When systematic traders first transcribe John Kelly's 1956 Bell Labs paper (*A New Interpretation of Information Rate*) into trading code, $90\%$ copy the casino binary formula **$f^* = p - \frac{q}{b}$** and wonder why it outputs `f* = 0.25` (`25%` of total equity), completely unsure whether `25%` means **"put 25% of portfolio notional into Apple stock"** or **"risk 25% of portfolio equity to my stop-loss"**! Confusing those two numbers by a factor of $10\times$ on a `-2.5%` stop-loss trade is the #1 position-sizing error in retail and emerging-quant trading! Verify exact both-convention outputs in our [Kelly Criterion Calculator](/calculators/kelly-criterion-calculator), inspect the [Half-Kelly Portfolio Leverage Engine](/entities/half-kelly-leverage-continuous-fractional-half-kelly-portfolio-leverage-criterion), and anchor in our [Kelly, Margin & Liquidation Hub](/guides/kelly-criterion-initial-variation-margin-liquidation-sizing-guide).

## Exact First-Principles Calculus Proof: Generalized Partial-Loss Kelly ($f^* = \frac{p}{a} - \frac{q}{b}$)

In a casino coin toss or expiring binary option, a losing bet forfeits **$100\%$ of staked capital** ($a = 1.00$). In liquid financial markets, a trade allocated fraction $f$ of total portfolio equity either **gains $+b$ per dollar allocated** with probability $p$ OR **hits a stop-loss losing $-a$ per dollar allocated** ($0 < a \le 1$) with probability $q = 1 - p$. Write single-trial expected logarithmic wealth growth $G(f) = \mathbb{E}[\ln(W_1 / W_0)]$ and set its first derivative $G'(f) = 0$:

```formula
Exact Generalized Discrete Binomial Kelly Criterion (Partial Loss -a, Partial Gain +b):
 Log-Growth Objective : G(f) = p * ln(1 + f * b) + q * ln(1 - f * a)
 First Derivative = 0 : G'(f) = [ p * b / (1 + f * b) ] - [ q * a / (1 - f * a) ] = 0
 Cross-Multiply & Solve : p*b*(1 - f*a) = q*a*(1 + f*b) => p*b - q*a = f*a*b*(p + q) = f*a*b
 1. Optimal Capital Allocation Fraction (f*_notional) :
 f*_notional = (p * b - q * a) / (a * b) = (p / a) - (q / b) = Expected_Edge / (a * b)
 2. Optimal Capital-at-Risk to Stop-Loss (r*_risk = f*_notional * a, letting R = b / a = Reward-to-Risk Ratio!):
 r*_risk = f*_notional * a = p - (q / R) <-- Classic Kelly gives RISK-AT-STOP %, NOT notional %!

Worked Swing-Trade Proof (Win Rate p = 45.0%, Loss Rate q = 55.0%, Stop-Loss a = -2.0%, Target Gain b = +6.0% => R = 3.0):
 1. Capital-at-Risk to Stop (r*_risk) = 0.45 - (0.55 / 3.0) = 0.45 - 0.1833 = 26.67% risk-to-stop (Full Kelly!)
 Institutional Quarter-Kelly Risk-at-Stop (0.25 * r*) = 6.67% of equity risked to the -2.0% stop (or 1–2% Desk Cap!)
 2. Notional Capital Allocation (f*_notional = r*_risk / a):
 Full Kelly Notional = 0.2667 / 0.02 = 13.33x Leverage! | Quarter-Kelly Notional = 3.33x Leverage!
 3. Check Second Derivative Concavity: G''(f) = -p*b^2/(1+fb)^2 - q*a^2/(1-fa)^2 < 0 strictly (Unique Global Max!)
```

Read Equations 1 and 2 side-by-side—that single algebraic identity resolves decades of confusion:
- **Classic $p - q/R$** (where $R = \text{Avg Win} / \text{Avg Loss}$) tells you **the fraction of account equity risked IF your stop-loss is hit** ($r^*_{\text{risk}}$)!
- Dividing $r^*_{\text{risk}}$ by percentage stop distance $a$ gives **notional position leverage** $f^*_{\text{notional}} = r^*_{\text{risk}} / a$!

![Step-by-step discrete Kelly derivation mapping empirical win rate and reward-to-risk ratio R into stop-loss risk fraction and notional leverage](/api/figure?type=flow&title=Translating%20Trade%20Statistics%20into%20Exact%20Kelly%20Risk%20%26%20Notional%20Size&subtitle=Separating%20Equity-at-Stop%20Risk%20%28r*%20%3D%20p%20-%20q%2FR%29%20from%20Notional%20Position%20Exposure%20%28f*%20%3D%20r*%20%2F%20stop%25%29.&steps=1.%20Audit%20Edge%20%3E%200%3A%3AVerify%20p*R%20-%20q%20%3E%200%20%28after%20commissions%20%26%20slippage!%29%3B%20if%20%3C%3D%200%2C%20f*%20%3D%200%20%28Do%20Not%20Trade%29%7C2.%20Solve%20Risk-at-Stop%3A%3ACompute%20r*_full%20%3D%20p%20-%20%281%20-%20p%29%2FR%20%3D%20fraction%20of%20equity%20lost%20on%20a%20full%20stop-out%7C3.%20Apply%20Safety%20Haircut%3A%3AScale%20down%20by%20c%20in%20%5B0.15%2C%200.50%5D%20for%20stop-gap%20slippage%20%26%20win-rate%20estimation%20error%7C4.%20Map%20to%20Notional%20Size%3A%3ANotional%20Exposure%20%3D%20%28c%20*%20r*_full%29%20%2F%20Stop_Loss_%25%20%28cap%20against%20broker%20Initial%20Margin!%29&metrics=BREAKEVEN%20WIN%20RATE%3A%3Ap_min%20%3D%201%20%2F%20%281%20%2B%20R%29%3A%3AAt%20R%3D3%3A1%2C%20breakeven%20p%20%3D%2025.0%25%7CHIGH-WR%20SCALPER%20%28p%3D70%25%2C%20R%3D1%29%3A%3Ar*%20%3D%20%2B40.0%25%3A%3ASensitive%20to%201%20gap%20loss%20%3E%203x%20stop!%7CTREND%20FOLLOWER%20%28p%3D35%25%2C%20R%3D3%29%3A%3Ar*%20%3D%20%2B13.3%25%3A%3AConvex%20right-tail%20payoff%20profile)

## Why Gap Slippage Beyond `-a` Shatters Un-Haircutted Discrete Kelly!

Look closely at the logarithm $\ln(1 - f \cdot a)$ inside the discrete Kelly objective: if your stop-loss is set at $a = 2.0\%$ and you lever notional to $f = 13.33\times$ (so $f \cdot a = 26.67\%$ loss on a normal stop), **what happens if an earnings gap or weekend FX jump opens `-8.0%` against you (`4x` your planned `-2.0%` stop)?** At $f = 13.33\times$ notional leverage, an $-8.0\%$ overnight gap inflicts $13.33 \times (-8.0\%) =$ **`-106.7%` total account bankruptcy** ($\ln(1 - 1.067)$ is undefined—total ruin)! Whenever actual worst-case gap loss $a_{\max}$ exceeds planned stop $a$, true discrete Kelly is bounded strictly below $1 / a_{\max}$—formalized in [Ralph Vince Optimal f largest-loss scaling](/guides/ralph-vince-optimal-f-empirical-trade-distribution-largest-loss)!

## Breakeven Win-Rate & Half-Kelly Risk-at-Stop Matrix Across Payoff Asymmetry ($R = b/a$)

Verify how win rate $p$ and net reward-to-risk ratio $R$ interact to determine **Half-Kelly Risk-at-Stop ($0.5 r^*$)** across four archetypal trading styles:

| Strategy Archetype | Win Rate ($p$) | Net Reward / Risk ($R = b/a$) | Breakeven Win Rate ($1/(1+R)$) | Expectancy per `$1` Risked | Full-Kelly Risk ($r^*$) | **Half-Kelly Risk ($0.5 r^*$)** |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Mean-Reversion Scalp** | $65.0\%$ | $1.00 : 1$ | $50.0\%$ | $+\$0.30$ | $30.0\%$ | **$15.0\%$** (Cap at $2\%$ for gap risk!) |
| **Swing Pullback Desk** | $50.0\%$ | $2.00 : 1$ | $33.3\%$ | $+\$0.50$ | $25.0\%$ | **$12.5\%$** |
| **Breakout Momentum** | $38.0\%$ | $3.00 : 1$ | $25.0\%$ | $+\$0.52$ | $17.3\%$ | **$8.67\%$** |
| **Macro Trend / Tail CTA** | $25.0\%$ | $6.00 : 1$ | $14.3\%$ | $+\$0.75$ | $12.5\%$ | **$6.25\%$** |
| **Zero-Edge Overtrader** | $40.0\%$ | $1.45 : 1$ | $40.8\%$ | **$-\$0.02$** | **$-1.38\% \to 0\%$** | **$0.00\%$** (Negative expectancy!) |

![Comparison of Full-Kelly Risk-at-Stop across equal +0.50 dollar expectancy systems proving higher win-rate lower-payoff systems have larger Kelly fractions](/api/figure?type=bars&title=Equal%20%2B%240.50%20Expectancy%20Paradox%3A%20Win%20Rate%20vs%20Payoff%20Asymmetry&subtitle=Three%20systems%20ALL%20earn%20%2B%240.50%20expected%20profit%20per%20%241%20risked%2C%20yet%20optimal%20Kelly%20risk%20differs%20by%204.5x!&steps=System%20A%20%28p%3D75%25%2C%20R%3D1%201%29%3A%3AExpectancy%20%3D%20%2B%240.50%2FR%20-%3E%20Full%20Kelly%20r*%20%3D%2050.0%25%20%28Lowest%20payoff%20variance%29%7CSystem%20B%20%28p%3D50%25%2C%20R%3D2%201%29%3A%3AExpectancy%20%3D%20%2B%240.50%2FR%20-%3E%20Full%20Kelly%20r*%20%3D%2025.0%25%20%28Moderate%20streak%20variance%29%7CSystem%20C%20%28p%3D25%25%2C%20R%3D5%201%29%3A%3AExpectancy%20%3D%20%2B%240.50%2FR%20-%3E%20Full%20Kelly%20r*%20%3D%2010.0%25%20%28Long%20losing%20streaks!%29%7CSystem%20D%20%28p%3D15%25%2C%20R%3D9%201%29%3A%3AExpectancy%20%3D%20%2B%240.50%2FR%20-%3E%20Full%20Kelly%20r*%20%3D%205.56%25%20%2818-loss%20streaks%20normal!%29&metrics=EXPECTANCY%20MYTH%3A%3ASame%20%2B%240.50%20!%3D%20Same%20f*%3A%3Ar*%20%3D%20Expectancy%20%2F%20R%2C%20NOT%20Expectancy%20alone!%7CALGEBRAIC%20IDENTITY%3A%3Ar*%20%3D%20E_R%20%2F%20R%3A%3A%28p*R%20-%20q%29%20%2F%20R%20divides%20edge%20by%20win%20multiple!%7C20-LOSS%20STREAK%20%40%20p%3D25%25%3A%3A0.32%25%20per%2020%3A%3AHappens%20~3x%20in%201%2C000%20trades!%7CSLIPPAGE%20DEDUCTION%3A%3ANet%20b%20%26%20Gross%20a%3A%3ASubtract%20fees%20from%20b%3B%20ADD%20fees%20to%20a!)

## The Equal-Expectancy Paradox: Why `r* = Expectancy / R`!

Look at the algebraic gem revealed in the chart above: since trade expectancy per dollar risked is $E_R = p R - q$, rewrite discrete Kelly as:
$$r^*_{\text{risk}} = p - \frac{q}{R} = \frac{p R - q}{R} = \frac{\text{Expectancy}}{R}$$
Two traders with the **exact same `+$0.50` expectancy per dollar risked** DO NOT bet the same fraction! A `p = 75%, R = 1` system has `r* = 0.50 / 1 = 50%`, whereas a `p = 25%, R = 5` trend-follower has `r* = 0.50 / 5 = 10%` because `25%` win-rate strategies naturally endure 12-to-18 consecutive losing trades!

## Connecting Discrete Binomial Kelly to Continuous Merton Diffusion & Lot Sizing

When trading continuous return distributions rather than fixed stop/target brackets, transition smoothly to [continuous Merton-Kelly leverage $\mu / \sigma^2$](/guides/continuous-merton-kelly-leverage-mu-over-sigma-squared-half-kelly) and [drawdown-constrained fractional Kelly](/guides/drawdown-constrained-fractional-kelly-probability-of-50pct-loss), convert `r*_risk` into exact currency lots via [FX pip-value lot sizing math](/guides/fx-pip-value-lot-sizing-quote-account-currency-conversion-math), and verify margin limits on [UK FCA](/regulator-index/fca) regulated venues in our [broker lookup directory](/broker-lookup/admirals).

## Frequently asked questions

### Why does John Kelly’s original 1956 paper connect optimal betting to Claude Shannon’s Information Theory?

Kelly examined a gambler receiving a noisy binary communication channel with crossover error probability q = 1 - p! On even-money odds (b = a = 1), optimal bet f* = p - q = 2p - 1 yields maximum asymptotic exponential growth rate ln(2) + p*ln(p) + q*ln(q)—which is literally Shannon’s channel capacity in nats per transmission!

### What happens if my strategy has a positive win rate (say 60%) but f* = p - q/R comes out negative?

A negative Kelly fraction (for example, p = 60%, q = 40%, R = 0.50 -> r* = 0.60 - 0.80 = -0.20) proves your strategy has NEGATIVE mathematical expectancy (0.60*0.50 - 0.40*1 = -$0.10 per $1 risked)! Unless you can take the opposite side of the trade (excluding transaction costs), optimal allocation is strictly f* = 0.

### How do brokerage commissions and bid-ask spread change b and a in the Kelly formula?

Suppose round-trip spread plus commission equals c = 0.15% of notional on a 1.0% stop / 2.0% target trade. Effective net win shrinks to b_net = 2.0% - 0.15% = 1.85%, while effective net loss widens to a_net = 1.0% + 0.15% = 1.15%—cutting R from 2.00 down to 1.61 and slashing Full Kelly by over 35%!

### Why do professional prop desks risk 0.5% to 2.0% per trade when Half-Kelly says 6% to 12%?

Three practical constraints: (1) Traders hold 5 to 15 correlated open positions simultaneously (so 10 positions x 1% risk = 10% aggregate correlated stop risk!); (2) Win rate p and payoff R drift across market regimes; and (3) Prop/institutional mandates cap maximum peak-to-trough drawdown at 10%–15%, requiring ~0.15x–0.25x Kelly.


## Source URLs

- https://bell-labs.co/pub/kelly-1956.pdf
- https://www.jstor.org/stable/1402502
- https://www.cfainstitute.org/insights/professional-learning/refresher-readings/2025/portfolio-risk-and-return-part-ii
- https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/handbook/cobs

## Citation

- APA: Elena Rostova, FRM, CQF. (2026). Discrete Binomial Kelly Criterion: Win Rate & Asymmetric Payoff Proof. QuantCalc Tools. https://quantcalctools.com/guides/discrete-binomial-kelly-criterion-win-rate-payoff-asymmetry-proof
- Canonical article: [Discrete Binomial Kelly Criterion: Win Rate & Asymmetric Payoff Proof](https://quantcalctools.com/guides/discrete-binomial-kelly-criterion-win-rate-payoff-asymmetry-proof)
- Site research index: [QuantCalc Tools](https://quantcalctools.com/llms-full.txt)
