# SOFR, ESTR & SONIA OIS FX Forward Discounting Math Guide

> Derive post-LIBOR dual-curve FX forward discounting under Credit Support Annexes (CSAs) using NY Fed SOFR, ECB ESTR, and BoE SONIA OIS discount factors.

Canonical: https://quantcalctools.com/guides/sofr-estr-sonia-ois-compounded-in-arrears-fx-forward-discounting
Last updated: 2026-11-15T12:54:41.641Z

**Publication:** QuantCalc Tools
**Category:** Covered Interest Parity Forwards
**Published:** 2026-11-13T22:45:25.915Z
**Author:** Elena Rostova, FRM, CQF (FRM, Certificate in Quantitative Finance (CQF))
**Reviewer:** Not recorded

## Answer-first summary

Post-LIBOR FX forwards price exclusively off collateralized overnight Risk-Free Rate (RFR) discount curves; changing CSA collateral currency from USD SOFR to EUR ESTR alters multi-year forward valuation.

## Key takeaways

- Post-LIBOR FX curves strip USD-collateralized foreign discount factors DF_f^USD-CSA(0, T) directly from NY Fed SOFR OIS, short-dated FX swaps (<=1Y), and RFR cross-currency basis swaps (>1Y).
- Plugging unadjusted domestic ESTR or TONA OIS discount factors into a 2-year forward omits the cross-currency basis and misprices EUR/USD by ~43 pips (and USD/JPY by ~90+ pips)!
- Changing an ISDA Credit Support Annex (CSA) from USD SOFR collateral to EUR ESTR collateral alters the present value of in-the-money FX forwards via Collateral Valuation Adjustment (ColVA).
- Secured RFRs (USD SOFR, CHF SARON) and unsecured RFRs (EUR ESTR, GBP SONIA, JPY TONA) differ in payment lags (0 to 2 business days) and day counts (ACT/360 vs ACT/365F).

## Related financial entities

- **Covered Interest Parity (CIP) FX Forward Points & Swap Engine** (CIP-FX-FORWARD) — product: Covered Interest Parity (CIP) FX Forward Points & Swap Engine (CIP-FX-FORWARD) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by BIS Monetary & Economic Dept (INTL), currently calibrated at -11.5 bps (Cross-Currency Basis) as of October 2026.
- **NY Fed SOFR Index ACT/360 In-Arrears Compounding Engine** (SOFR-INDEX-ACT360) — product: NY Fed SOFR Index ACT/360 In-Arrears Compounding Engine (SOFR-INDEX-ACT360) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by NY Fed Reference Rates (US), currently calibrated at 4.4151% (90-Day Annualized) as of October 2026.
- **Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR)** (SOFR) — product: Broad volume-weighted median measure of the cost of borrowing cash overnight collateralized by U.S. Treasury securities on an ACT/360 basis.

## Analysis

Following the global cessation of USD, GBP, EUR, CHF, and JPY IBOR fixings, institutional FX swap and multi-year forward desks no longer plug unsecured term rates into Covered Interest Parity—every interdealer curve strips **collateralized overnight Risk-Free Rate (RFR) OIS discount factors** anchored by the [NY Fed SOFR Index ACT/360](/entities/sofr-index-act360-ny-fed-sofr-index-act-360-in-arrears-compounding-engine), ECB `€STR`, BoE `SONIA`, and BoJ `TONA`! Even more subtly, under bilateral ISDA **Credit Support Annexes (`CSAs`)**, two counterparties trading the *exact same* 3-year `EUR/USD` forward face different present-value discount curves depending on whether Variation Margin is posted in **USD cash (remunerated at SOFR)** or **EUR cash (remunerated at €STR)**! Model daily compounded RFRs in our [SOFR overnight compounding & carry calculator](/calculators/sofr-compounding-carry-calculator) and ground baseline forward math in our [Covered Interest Parity & FX Forward Points master guide](/guides/covered-interest-parity-fx-forward-points-cross-currency-basis-guide).

## Exact CSA Collateralized Dual-Curve FX Forward Discounting Equation

Suppose a dealer executes an outright forward exchanging $1$ unit of Foreign Currency $f$ for $K$ units of USD at maturity $T$ (with Spot settling at $T_s$), collateralized daily in **USD cash earning overnight [SOFR](/entities/sofr-benchmark-rate)**. What discount factor prices the Foreign Currency leg? **NOT the pure domestic foreign OIS curve $DF_f^{\text{OIS}}(0, T)$!** Because Variation Margin is posted in USD rather than Currency $f$, discounting Currency-$f$ cashflows requires the **USD-Collateralized Foreign Discount Curve $DF_f^{\text{USD-CSA}}(0, T)$**, stripped simultaneously from market FX forwards and cross-currency basis swaps! Setting inception NPV $= 0$ yields the exact **Post-LIBOR Dual-Curve Forward Identity**:
$$F(0, T) = S_0 \times \frac{DF_f^{\text{USD-CSA}}(T_s, T)}{DF_{\text{USD}}^{\text{SOFR}}(T_s, T)}, \qquad DF_f^{\text{USD-CSA}}(0, T) = DF_f^{\text{OIS}}(0, T) \cdot \exp\!\big(+\alpha_{\text{basis}}(T) \cdot T\big)$$

## Worked 2-Year `EUR/USD` OIS Compounded Index & CSA Discounting Audit

```formula
Worked 2-Year (730-Day) EUR/USD Dual-Curve Forward & Daily SOFR Index Compounding Audit
1) NY Fed SOFR Index In-Arrears Compounding Check (Quarter 1: d = 91 Calendar Days):
 Published NY Fed SOFR Index Start = 1.14250000; End = 1.15564215
 Exact Compounded Annualized Rate R_comp (ACT/360) = (1.15564215 / 1.14250000 - 1) * (360 / 91)
 = 0.01150298 * 3.956044 = 4.5506% (vs 4.525% simple avg!)

2) 2-Year EUR/USD Outright Forward Under USD-SOFR CSA Collateral (Spot S_0 = 1.08500, T = 2.00 Yrs):
 2Y USD SOFR OIS Zero Discount Factor DF_USD(Ts, 2Y) [4.35% ann ACT/360] = 0.916324
 2Y Pure Domestic ECB ESTR OIS Discount Factor DF_EUR_OIS(Ts, 2Y) [2.55%] = 0.950421
 2Y EUR/USD Cross-Currency Basis Swap (ESTR - 19.0 bps vs SOFR flat) => Basis Factor = 1.003807!
 USD-Collateralized EUR Discount Factor DF_EUR_CSA = 0.950421 * 1.003807 = 0.954039!
 Exact 2Y EUR/USD Forward Outright F(0, 2Y) = 1.08500 * (0.954039 / 0.916324) = 1.129654 (+446.54 pips!)
 (Using unadjusted domestic ESTR DF_EUR_OIS = 0.950421 gives 1.125370 -> 42.84 PIPS PRICING ERROR!)

3) USD-CSA vs EUR-CSA Valuation Gap on a Seasoned +$5,000,000 In-the-Money 2Y Forward:
 Discounted under USD SOFR CSA (DF = 0.916324): PV_USD_CSA = $5,000,000 * 0.916324 = $4,581,620
 Discounted under EUR ESTR CSA (Implied USD DF = 0.916324 / 1.003807 = 0.912850): PV_EUR_CSA = $4,564,250
 PURE CSA COLLATERAL SWITCH VALUATION DELTA (ColVA) = -$17,370 on $5M MTM!
```

Look at Step 2 and Step 3:
- Plugging pure domestic `€STR` OIS discount factors into a 2-year `EUR/USD` forward without the `-19 bps` cross-currency basis adjustment misprices the forward by **42.84 pips ($428,400 per €100M)**!
- Even after locking in the exact market forward $F$, switching an ISDA CSA from **USD collateral** to **EUR collateral** shifts the present value of an existing $+$5\text{M}$ mark-to-market position by **$$17,370$ (`Collateral Valuation Adjustment / ColVA`)**!

![Post-LIBOR dual-curve FX forward stripping and CSA collateral currency discounting workflow](/api/figure?type=flow&title=Dual-Curve%20OIS%20%26%20CSA-Collateralized%20FX%20Discounting%20Pipeline&subtitle=Stripping%20USD-CSA%20foreign%20discount%20curves%20from%20SOFR%20OIS%2C%20FX%20swap%20points%2C%20and%20XCCY%20basis%20swaps.&steps=1.%20Bootstrap%20SOFR%20OIS%3A%3AStrip%20native%20USD%20SOFR%20discount%20curve%20DF_USD%280%2C%20T%29%7C2.%20Strip%20Short%20FX%20Swaps%3A%3AUse%20%3C%3D1Y%20FX%20swap%20points%20to%20imply%20DF_f%5EUSD-CSA%280%2C%20T%29%7C3.%20Splice%20%3E1Y%20XCCY%20Swaps%3A%3ACombine%20ESTR%2FSONIA%2FTONA%20OIS%20%2B%20RFR%20XCCY%20basis%20%3E1Y%7C4.%20Adjust%20Bilateral%20CSA%3A%3AApply%20ColVA%20shift%20if%20counterparty%20posts%20EUR%2FGBP%2FMulti-CCY&metrics=IBOR%20CESSATION%3A%3A100%25%20RFR%3A%3ASOFR%2C%20ESTR%2C%20SONIA%2C%20TONA%2C%20SARON%7C2Y%20PURE%20OIS%20ERROR%3A%3A42.84%20Pips%3A%3AOmitting%20-19bp%20XCCY%20basis%20on%202Y%7CCSA%20SWITCH%20COLVA%3A%3A38%20bps%20%282Y%29%3A%3A2%20*%2019bp%20basis%20PV%20discount%20shift%7CCHEAPEST%20TO%20DELIVER%3A%3AMulti-CCY%20CSA%3A%3AEmbedded%20collateral%20choice%20option!)

## Cheapest-to-Deliver (`CTD`) Collateral Optionality in Multi-Currency CSAs!

Legacy bilateral ISDA CSAs signed in the 2000s often allow the collateral poster to **choose daily whether to post USD, EUR, GBP, or JPY cash**! Which currency will a rational bank post? Whichever currency carries the **highest FX-swap-implied USD funding return** (i.e. a currency trading at a positive basis, or pure USD when EUR/JPY basis is `-25 bps`)! Consequently, multi-currency CSAs discount every derivative along the **envelope maximum of CSA curves (`Cheapest-to-Deliver Collateral Curve`)**, priced via stochastic basis models! Check short-tenor forward points in our [FX forward points & carry calculator](/calculators/fx-forward-calculator).

## Post-LIBOR Global Overnight Risk-Free Rate (RFR) OIS Benchmark Matrix

| Currency | Official RFR Benchmark | Administrator & Fixing Time | Secured vs Unsecured | Day-Count & OIS Payment Lag |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| `USD` | **SOFR** | Federal Reserve Bank of NY (`08:00 ET`) | **Secured** (UST Tri-Party/GCF Repo) | `ACT/360`, **2 business days** (`T+2` pay) |
| `EUR` | **€STR** | European Central Bank (`08:00 CET`) | **Unsecured** wholesale deposit | `ACT/360`, **1 business day** (`T+1` pay) |
| `GBP` | **SONIA** | Bank of England (`09:00 London`) | **Unsecured** wholesale deposit | **`ACT/365F`**, **0-day lag** (`T+0` same day!) |
| `JPY` | **TONA** | Bank of Japan (`10:00 Tokyo`) | **Unsecured** call money | **`ACT/365F`**, **2 business days** (`T+2` pay) |
| `CHF` | **SARON** | SIX Swiss Exchange (`18:00 CET` close) | **Secured** (SNB Swiss Repo) | `ACT/360`, **2 business days** (`T+2` pay) |

![2-Year EUR/USD FX Forward Points decomposition comparing Pure Domestic OIS Differential, Compounding Uplift, and XCCY Basis Contribution](/api/figure?type=bars&title=2-Year%20EUR%2FUSD%20Forward%20Points%20Attribution%20%28%2B446.5%20Pips%20Total%29&subtitle=Breaking%20down%20how%20OIS%20spread%20%28%2B396.2p%29%2C%20compounding%20%28%2B7.5p%29%2C%20and%20XCCY%20basis%20%28%2B42.8p%29%20sum%20to%20market%20quotes.&steps=Simple%20Rate%20Spread%3A%3A%2B396.2%20pips%20from%204.35%25%20SOFR%20minus%202.55%25%20ESTR%20simple%20diff%7C2Y%20Compounding%20Effect%3A%3A%2B7.5%20pips%20from%20exponential%2Fannual%20OIS%20compounding%20curvature%7CXCCY%20Basis%20%28-19%20bps%29%3A%3A%2B42.8%20pips%20added%20by%20USD%20collateral%20scarcity%20premium!%7CTotal%20Live%202Y%20Quote%3A%3A%2B446.5%20pips%20%28%241.129654%20outright%20on%201.08500%20spot%29&metrics=PURE%20OIS%20SPREAD%3A%3A%2B396.2%20Pips%3A%3A88.7%25%20of%202-year%20swap%20points%7CCOMPOUNDING%20LIFT%3A%3A%2B7.5%20Pips%3A%3A1.7%25%20multi-year%20curvature%7CXCCY%20BASIS%20LIFT%3A%3A%2B42.8%20Pips%3A%3A9.6%25%20basis%20contribution!%7CTOTAL%202Y%20OUTRIGHT%3A%3A%2B446.5%20Pips%3A%3AExact%20USD-CSA%20arbitrage%20quote)

## Marking Seasoned Forwards to Market & Managing Resetting XCCY Swaps

Once a 2-year forward ages 6 months into a 1.5-year off-market contract, apply the exact USD-CSA discount curve derived above inside [mark-to-market valuation of seasoned FX forwards](/guides/mark-to-market-valuation-seasoned-fx-forward-discounted-pv-math) and [MTM resetting cross-currency swaps](/guides/marked-to-market-resetting-cross-currency-swap-notional-rebalancing). Audit counterparty margin rules on the [Central Bank of Ireland register](/regulator-index/cbi) and browse all 20 guides on the [FX Forward Points & Basis Topic Hub](/topics/covered-interest-parity-forwards).

## Frequently asked questions

### Why can’t you discount EUR cashflows at pure ECB €STR OIS when valuing a USD-collateralized EUR/USD forward?

Because if EUR/USD moves in your favor, the counterparty posts USD cash collateral remunerated at USD SOFR—NOT EUR cash remunerated at €STR! Hedging the EUR sensitivity requires funding via the EUR/USD FX swap market, embedding the cross-currency basis.

### How does the NY Fed SOFR Index simplify in-arrears compounding calculations?

Published daily by the New York Fed to 8 decimal places, the SOFR Index accumulates every business day’s overnight repo compounding factor since April 2, 2018—reducing any multi-month compounded SOFR calculation to a single division (Index_end / Index_start - 1) * (360 / d)!

### Why did interdealer cross-currency basis swaps switch from 3M LIBOR vs 3M EURIBOR to RFR in-arrears?

With USD LIBOR, GBP LIBOR, JPY LIBOR, and CHF LIBOR permanently discontinued between 2021 and 2023, ARRC and global RFR working groups standardized interdealer cross-currency swaps on quarterly compounded-in-arrears RFRs (SOFR vs ESTR, SONIA, TONA, SARON).

### What is "Cheapest-to-Deliver" (CTD) collateral optionality in legacy ISDA CSAs?

Legacy CSAs allowing a party to post either USD, EUR, or GBP cash give the collateral poster a free option to switch into whichever currency has the lowest net funding drag—forcing quants to discount trades at the worst-case envelope curve.


## Source URLs

- https://www.newyorkfed.org/markets/reference-rates/sofr-averages-and-index
- https://www.ecb.europa.eu/stats/financial_markets_and_interest_rates/euro_short-term_rate/html/index.en.html
- https://www.isda.org/2021/05/11/isda-2021-interest-rate-derivatives-definitions/

## Citation

- APA: Elena Rostova, FRM, CQF. (2026). SOFR, ESTR & SONIA OIS Compounded In-Arrears FX Forward Discounting Math. QuantCalc Tools. https://quantcalctools.com/guides/sofr-estr-sonia-ois-compounded-in-arrears-fx-forward-discounting
- Canonical article: [SOFR, ESTR & SONIA OIS Compounded In-Arrears FX Forward Discounting Math](https://quantcalctools.com/guides/sofr-estr-sonia-ois-compounded-in-arrears-fx-forward-discounting)
- Site research index: [QuantCalc Tools](https://quantcalctools.com/llms-full.txt)
